/ One watch prioritizes comfort, the other endurance.
Reya Collins is a tech reviewer who reviews those products which individuals wear, put on their desks and pin to their bags and she does not even take them lightly. She studied consumer behaviour and has 5 years of writing experience in this field. She joined as a review writer of wearables, smart home and different accessories of the tech industry. She even values the purchase of 100 dollars of any consumer and this thing reflects in her writing style as well. One more thing about her is that she is extremely creative and loves to paint in her free time and her favourite painter is Alex Katz.
Quick verdict:
If you have an iPhone, value the lightness of the band and don’t want to feel discomfort at night and need a smartwatch that integrates well with your health and fitness needs, choose the Apple Watch 11. If you use an Android device, need something more classic and watch-like and want to forget about charging your smartwatch every day, go for the Galaxy Watch8 Classic.
Galaxy Watch8 Classic works with Android, but Samsung phones provide the most complete experience. Apple prioritizes comfort and ecosystem integration. Samsung prioritizes traditional design, physical controls and battery life. There’s no absolute victor in this case and your phone plays the key role in making a choice.
I’m keeping this table short on purpose, specs alone don’t tell you how a watch actually feels to wear.
| Feature | Apple Watch Series 11 | Galaxy Watch8 Classic |
|---|---|---|
| Phone compatibility | iPhone only | Android only |
| Case sizes | 42mm / 46mm | 46mm only |
| Display | LTPO3 OLED | Super AMOLED |
| Peak brightness | 2,000 nits | Up to 3,000 nits |
| Battery rating | Up to 24 hours | Up to 30 hours (AOD) |
| Case material | Aluminum / titanium | Stainless steel |
| Storage | 64GB | 64GB |
| GPS | GPS | Dual-frequency GPS |
| Controls | Digital Crown + side button | Rotating bezel + buttons |
| Software | watchOS 26 | Wear OS |
| Cellular | Available | Available |
On paper, Samsung Galaxy wins the brightness and battery numbers and Apple wins on size flexibility. In daily wear, the gap felt smaller than the numbers suggest, more on that below.
The Apple Watch remains a pretty good smartwatch. At a glance, the Galaxy Watch8 Classic looks like a watch that your grandfather would have worn until it illuminates.
Does the additional weight really feel a premium or just plain heavy? After 14 days of using this: it feels premium for the first couple hours of the day but towards the evening starts to feel like a tiny dumbbell when I’m typing at a desk. A mechanical dive watch will take you right to the heart of the dive.
This is where the two watches begin to differ most and is the section that most reviews miss.
I wore each watch every night for seven days. The Series 11 disappeared on my wrist after about 20 minutes of lying down. It was there most nights and I truly forgot about it. It was always noticeable when I would sleep on my side with my wrist under the pillow, I would wake up one or two nights and remove it before going back to sleep.
In short, even though the Watch8 Classic feels like a real watch, it doesn’t necessarily make for a more comfortable experience. Whether overnight sleep tracking is important to you or not, the more you are comfortable sleeping, the closer you are to being accurate.
Rather than list OS features, here’s how each performed on real tasks over three weeks:
| Task | Which felt better |
|---|---|
| Notifications | Roughly tied, both surface and clear notifications cleanly |
| Replying to messages | Apple, slightly, dictation and Scribble feel more reliable |
| Maps / navigation | Roughly tied, depends on Google Maps vs Apple Maps preference |
| Music controls | Roughly tied |
| Third-party apps | Apple, more polished watch apps overall |
| Voice assistant | Samsung, Gemini feels noticeably more capable than Siri for open-ended questions |
| Watch faces | Samsung, more customization depth |
| Phone integration | Depends entirely on phone brand |
| Smart-home controls | Roughly tied if you’re in either ecosystem properly |
The Watch8 Classic by Samsung comes integrated with Gemini and is a far more helpful assistant than one that could just set timers and check weather. Siri from Apple focuses more on accessing data from the health app on the device itself.
Which ecosystem makes the watch independent from your phone? Neither, both rely quite a lot on the paired phone. But the experience of using apps independently was better with Samsung because of the presence of Gemini.
According to Samsung’s spec sheet, the device’s peak brightness is up to 3,000 nits, compared to Apple’s 2,000 nits. On a spec sheet, that’s a blowout. In practice?
I was able to read both displays outside in the full sun at noon without shading. The disparity was only apparent in the most extreme environments (reflective surfaces such as snow or a car windshield) and was not significant enough to matter much for the Watch8 Classic. They are the same inside, where you sit at your desk, in a dim restaurant.
But the real difference between the displays is:
Is it possible to detect the tint difference outside? In extreme glare only. This spec is not as relevant as the marketing terms to 95% of the use.
Apple’s Digital Crown is exact, touchable and predictable. Scrolling through a lengthy list of notifications or app icons feels controlled and predictable. It’s a known quantity, if you have ever used an Apple Watch before.
Samsung’s bezel rotation is just more entertaining to use and can be quicker when you have to scroll through a long list of apps, notifications or long-list of items. It’s nice to have a workout menu to spin through rather than turn a little crown. In terms of scrolling speed, it’s the bezel, you get more screen real estate for every physical motion.
Apple makes up for it with precision. The Crown’s fine control allows easier selection of a single small item (such as a specific song in a playlist). The bezel is more a blunt tool suited for big jumps, less one suited for pinpoint selection.
Verdict on controls: bezel for speed and satisfaction, crown for precision. Out of the two I’d probably go with the bezel, it looks better in the hand.
This is the part I worked the hardest on as it’s where most purchases really occur.
The basics are dual covered and that’s heart rate, ECG, blood oxygen, wrist temperature, stress tracking and cycle tracking. Where they diverge:
Topped with Body Composition analysis (body fat, skeletal muscle and water estimates using an impedance-based method), an AGEs Index, Antioxidant Index and sleep apnea detection.
The extras Apple offers include hypertension alerts (which are a background check that alerts you to possible chronically high blood pressure over time) as well as its Sleep Score, heart-rate and wrist-temperature monitoring capabilities.
| Category | Apple | Samsung |
|---|---|---|
| Core health tracking | Strong | Strong |
| ECG | Yes | Yes |
| Sleep | Simpler insights | More granular |
| Body composition | No | Yes |
| Blood pressure | Hypertension notifications | Blood pressure feature |
| Recovery/trend depth | Strong | Strong |
| Medical usefulness | Don’t overstate | Don’t overstate |
What are the features that are useful and what are the features that are just interesting numbers? After a couple of checks, Body Composition was just another novelty to me. I found it had shifted enough from check to check that I didn’t rely on it for anything more than a general indication of a trend.
In this instance, however, the messages that would be received about high blood pressure would be the ones you don’t want, but would want. As for relevance to the real world, ECG would have been the most stable health attribute that resulted in an important event to the doctor.
Apple’s watch would certainly be a better option if your main goal is health tracking, as it seems the company is looking to make the data from the health app part of your overall health profile, if you already have an iPhone to keep track of your health anyway. The big one is from Samsung, but the smart one is from Apple.
I went through the same nights on both watches at the same time (one on each wrist, not ideal but had to do it in order to be a fair comparison).
The Watch8 Classic creates truly comprehensive sleep graphs: Stage breakdowns, movement, heart rate during sleep and breathing disturbance flags. However, sleep stage transitions were not a perfect match with my personal memory of waking up briefly — a few nights, it recorded a sleep stage transition that was not what I recalled.
A single number is simpler, easier to digest and has less fine-grained stage data, but there were fewer moments in which I questioned myself about what Sleep Score is telling me, with Apple’s new score.
Not all the metrics are necessarily the best sleep tracker, it’s the metrics that you would actually do something about. That’s Apple’s easier goal, for me. For those who wish to get into all the transitions of the dig and tie them to their day, Samsung has more raw material.
A practical suggestion: When you’re not using the device for sleep tracking but you do every night, the Watch8 Classic did not have a noticeable overnight battery drain.
These are not Garmin replacements and I wouldn’t suggest either of them to someone training for an ultramarathon. However, they are both very durable for regular gym users and casual runners.
Apple had a little less friction for someone who exercises 3-4 times a week and who doesn’t want to think about it too hard to get clean data. If you’re a fans-of-trends-and-recovery-fans person, Samsung has more to chew on.
On paper, Samsung’s dual-frequency GPS (L1+L5) is a real strength. I timed the distance with both watches as I ran the same route near buildings and through a park as well as along open streets for the 5K race.
Results: The two tracks were virtually the same in open areas. Near downtown the Watch8 Classic’s track was straighter and more consistent than the Series 11, which was prone to the sort of drift you’d expect when single-frequency GPS bounced off buildings.
Does it have noticeable real-world implications? Well, yes – provided you are running or cycling in urban areas on a regular basis. If you are primarily riding on parks, trails or suburban streets, then you won’t notice any difference.
The Samsung spec sheet lists 30 hours while Apple’s specs call it “24 hours. Those numbers, alone, are not very helpful, as they are based on an idealized use pattern, namely in a fairly light load. Instead, I did the same for both of the watches over the four day cycle:
Day 1: Always on display, notifications (normal volume) and a 45-minute strength session tracked with both watches. At the end of the day: Series 11 was around 45%, Watch8 Classic was around 62%.
Day 2: Overnight sleep tracking Charged each to 100%, slept through an entire night of tracking and then a regular day of notifications and AOD. On the next evening: Series 11 sat at 38% and Watch8 Classic at 58%. The Samsung watch had a significantly lower overnight drain specifically (bed time to wake up) about half that of the Apple Watch.
Day 3: GPS workout A 50 minute outdoor GPS run, plus normal daily usage around it. The largest battery consumption for both watches is GPS. Although the Run has a dual-frequency GPS, which offers greater accuracy, it saw a slight decrease of around 7-8% for the same run.
Day 4: No exercise, heavy smartwatch use, Calls, message replies, music streaming via Bluetooth, frequent screen checks throughout the day. Both were faster than a normal day, but the difference remained at a consistent level; Series 11 was around 20-25% faster while Watch8 Classic was around 40% faster.
The remaining charge after 24 hours of the same mixed-use averaged over the test days, for the Series 11, will be in the 35-45% range in the evening by the end of the day and most people will want (or need) an evening top up. The Watch8 Classic always hits 50-60% and leaves plenty of time to spare.
Just how much is Samsung good for? Mixed daily use with AOD on, the Watch8 Classic will last about 30-50% longer than the Series 11, depending on the amount of screen-on time and GPS activity. It’s not a “30 vs 24” difference on paper, it’s a difference on an actual day.
How many nights can you reasonably monitor prior to charging? Apple: Be prepared to pay for nightly tracking, usually getting a quick recharging session during the day to get through to bedtime. Samsung allows you to take a full day and night of sleep data and then some, while getting a decent amount of battery life back as well, wherever tracking is a nightly routine, that battery life is the one that matters.
Which one drains the least battery when using GPS for workouts? It’s by a few percent per session, but when you add it up over the course of the day if you’re running or cycling most days of the week, the Watch8 Classic is consistently, by a few percent, better.
They both charge using a magnetic puck charger. In practical terms, it’s how you can charge your habit into your day.
The Series 11 has allowed me to get in the habit of charging it quickly in the shower (10-15 minutes), which charges a decent amount of battery and maintains sleep tracking without interruption. I would often be able to charge for a few minutes as I made a cup of coffee and not have to think about it each day with the Watch8 Classic.
10 minutes of charging = how many hours of use? During testing, I’ve got about 8-10 hours of normal use from each watch after 10-minutes of top up – which is about as different as it can get, because the crucial difference is how often you need to top it up, not how much you can get out of each session.
Do NOT make this as a footnote in a specs table; it should be the first choice you make.
iPhone Owner → Apple Watch Series 11. The full feature set of Wear OS doesn’t support pairing with the iPhone.
Android owner → Galaxy Watch8 Classic (or other wear os watch). It’s not possible to get Apple Watch and Android to connect together at all.
If you are considering these two watches and haven’t already got the matching phone, stop. Your phone in your pocket has already decided for you.
Samsung Phone vs Other Android Phones
That part of the Android side of things which isn’t talked about enough: Android compatibility doesn’t equate to an identical Android experience on all Android phones.
The Samsung Galaxy app integration, handling of notifications and the ability to use. The Samsung Galaxy app integration, handling of notifications and the ability to use Samsung features was significantly better.
The same watch with a non-Samsung Android phone (I used a Pixel) performed just fine on the basics (notifications, calls, fitness tracking, etc.), but some Samsung-specific features were a bit rough around the edges and opening the device required a bit more work.
Is there any loss in a non-Samsung Android phone? Not the main experience, but you lose some of the ecosystem “glue”. Should you purchase the Watch8 Classic explicitly, then a Galaxy handset will provide you the maximum potential of what it can do.
The Series 11’s display was made more scratch resistant. The Classic is designed hand-in-hand with a stainless-steel case that’s 5ATM water resistant, IP68 dust resistant and has undergone MIL-STD-810H testing for durability.
After 3 weeks of normal usage (gym class, a few light blows to the doorframe, one knock off a coffee table), both were OK. The steel case and bezel of the Watch8 Classic was slightly more reassuring for the rougher days, but the Series 11 had a more precious feel, as so do most Apple products.
Which would I prefer to wear on a bit of a rough outdoor day? The Watch8 Classic, for the sole purpose of “I’m not babying this thing.
This is not just a case of size on paper; weight and thickness are important as well as diameter.
The Series 11’s 42mm case is a clear win for smaller wrists and even the larger 46mm Apple option is lighter than the Watch8 Classic’s case, which only comes in one size. The Watch8 Classic is actually going to be a bit more suited to larger wrists, as its stainless steel case and larger size means there’s no smaller option. When choosing a Classic wrist, if you have a smaller wrist, it’s best to try it on before purchasing as the weight is subjectively more palpable than the diameter number.
It’s important to note that both of these are not the best way to compare them by their launching price as the true cost of ownership comes after the checkout page.
Watch: The Watch8 Classic is going to be priced in the vicinity of or at the same price as, the entry Series 11, primarily due to the stainless-steel construction and absence of a lower-priced smaller-case option. This is balanced by the fact that Apple has the 42mm at a lower price than the 46mm.
LTE premium: Both LTE premiums charge about the same range of premium for the cellular models in addition to a monthly per-line charge from the carrier, often ignoring recurring cost of both watches. If you are not already aware, then you do not need stand-alone cellular, as most owners do not use it very often.
Bands: this is where things get difficult. The official Apple bands cost money and changing them out regularly can quickly accumulate. A high-quality fitness tracker can cost a band the same amount. Samsung’s official bands are more affordable and both platforms have a vibrant third-party market, although third-party bands are more restricted on the Apple side due to the company’s band-attachment system.
Charger: in the box at no extra charge with either.
Subscription price: both watches have subscription pricing for the basic health and fitness data; this is important to note as some competitors (Whoop, for instance) embed subscription fees into the base price. There are optional extras, such as Apple Fitness+ and Samsung’s top health-coaching packages, but they aren’t mandatory.
Ecosystem costs: The true concealed number is the cost to the ecosystem. Both watches work best inside their respective ecosystems, so switching platforms later can make the original purchase less convenient.
Durability: I did a bit of testing on the Watch8 Classic and found that the stainless steel and glass around the sapphire crystal were very durable and should last a while longer, possibly until it’s time for a screen replacement or case replacement. The aluminum case is lighter, but will show visible signs of wear after 2-3 years of daily use, while the titanium version of Series 11 will be more expensive but should last longer.
Which watch offers you the most value for your money? The Watch8 Classic’s specs, including steel case, dual-frequency GPS, additional health sensors, allow it to offer more hardware for the price, making it a better “spec per dollar” option.
It’s not just how good the hardware is, but also the software, the apps and the depth of the ecosystem that Apple has here and that’s a good thing if you’re a current iPhone owner, but a bad thing if you’re just looking at this from a hardware to price perspective.
Purchase the Series 11 when:
Purchase Watch8 Classic If:
These both are not appropriate for everyone and it’s best to state it clearly:
Based on three weeks of daily hands-on use:
| Category | Apple Watch Series 11 | Galaxy Watch8 Classic |
|---|---|---|
| Design | 4.5/5 | 4.8/5 |
| Comfort | 4.8/5 | 4.0/5 |
| Display | 4.7/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Smart Features | 4.8/5 | 4.6/5 |
| Health Tracking | 4.8/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Fitness | 4.8/5 | 4.6/5 |
| Sleep Tracking | 4.7/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Battery | 4.0/5 | 4.8/5 |
| Controls | 4.6/5 | 5.0/5 |
| Ecosystem | 5.0/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Overall | 4.7/5 | 4.6/5 |
They are two good watches that arose from two very different ideas about what a smartwatch should be. The Apple Watch Series 11 is the smartwatch to buy if you’re an Apple fan — it’s lighter, more comfortable to wear overnight and seamlessly integrates with all of Apple’s products.
If you’re an Android person who needs your smartwatch to feel, look and act like a real wristwatch, the Galaxy Watch8 Classic is the better option.
If given a choice, use your cell phone to choose. All the remaining points in this article are the tie-breakers of the existing ecosystem you are in.
If you are looking for other options. Read:
Google Pixel Watch 4 vs Pixel Watch 3
There are a ton of low-tech gift lists created around items which seem like they are “cool” in the photo but never get used. For…
Be respectful and constructive. Have a question or feedback? We’d love to hear from you. Contact us at contact@thetweaks.com